MENU

Who Experiences the Lowest Levels of Cooperation in Your Company

 Frontline leaders walking the factory floor

Employee Experience, High-trust leadership, Productivity

And why that’s a big problem for your business.

The management challenge facing frontline workers might feel uniquely modern. It’s not.

A recent study of military desertions during the U.S. Civil War uncovered an astonishing fact. For all the history books written about Robert E. Lee and Ulysses S. Grant, it was the low-level captains, not the generals, who had the biggest impact on desertion.

“At least in terms of keeping its men from deserting, a captain was more than three times as influential as any general,” reports The Washington Post. “… an army with excellent captains and a mediocre corps of generals would be several times more effective than one with a brilliant general and crummy captains.”

Poke your head into any 21st-century organization and you’ll find a higher standard of hygiene, but the same management dilemma: Frontline leaders are critical to success, yet they often have worse experiences at work than their peers.  

When frontline leaders don't have what they need to succeed, workplace performance suffers.

Frontline leaders experience the least cooperation

Your frontline leaders are likely experiencing the lowest levels of cooperation in your organization, according to Great Place To Work data from more than 1.3 million employees.

At typical workplaces, only six in 10 frontline leaders find it easy to cooperate with their colleagues, compared to eight in 10 at high-trust workplaces.

Our work shows that frontline leaders consistently experience lower levels of cooperation than employees at every other level, from individual contributors to the C-suite.

Why does that matter? Cooperation is tied to business performance. It’s the No. 1 driver of productivity we see in our work helping leaders build high-trust workplaces.

High-trust workplaces close the gap

How frontline leaders experience cooperation depends largely on the level of trust across the organization.  

The amount spent globally on leadership training is expected to surpass $73 billion by 2034.  Yet frontline managers are overlooked.

Almost 60% of managers say they never receive any training when they transition into their first leadership role.

“Almost two-thirds of organizations spend less than $500 per year on management development per person,” writes Soren Kaplan in Inc. “That’s often less than the cost of an hour of executive coaching.”

The result? Frontline managers are often left to figure it out on their own. More than three-fourths (77%) of frontline managers say they can’t get the guidance they need, per a recent Dayforce survey.

Great workplaces do it differently.

At Target, leaders are developed continuously through opportunities like the company’s Store Director Development Program, which offers peer learning for its 2,000 store directors.

“The role of a middle manager can’t be underestimated,” says Melissa Kremer, chief human resources officer at Target. “These leaders are an important part of the experience a team member has at work, and they play an outsized role in unlocking engagement, contribution, and productivity within their teams.”

Marriott International launched a dedicated program called “Elevate” to bring one-on-one coaching to its frontline. The more than 2,600 associates who participated were twice as likely to change jobs within the organization and 5.5 times more likely to get promoted.

What every leader needs to ask

Frontline leaders play a critical role in workforce performance, whether you run a 19th century continental army or a modern-day technology firm.

The question every organization should ask:

❓ Are your frontline leaders getting what they need to succeed?

Leadership blind spots are an old story.  

In their study of Civil War leadership, the researchers found there was no reliable way to predict which soldiers would become the most effective frontline leaders. Their impact only became clear over time, after measuring their impact. One sobering way of identifying a great Civil War captain: They had a much higher mortality rate, “consistent with leadership-by-example or leading-from-the-front.”

Modern leaders can rely on better measures of leadership effectiveness. Great Place To Work helps organizations measure trust across their entire workforce — revealing the overlooked gaps that threaten future performance.

You need your leaders to collaborate effectively, and drive vital innovation and workplace transformation. It’s time to stop treating them like soldiers on the fields of Gettysburg in the Civil War.


Ted Kitterman